350 Montana is an all-volunteer not-for-profit organization. We were an “intervener” in NorthWestern Energy’s “merger docket” with the Montana Public Service Commission (PSC). Members of our leadership team spoke out at the meeting when Commissioners voted 3 to 2 on Nov 10 to allow NorthWestern’s $15 billion merger with Black Hills Corp.
We went to court after we watched commissioners go into a confidential session during a public meeting, which is illegal under Montana’s open meeting law and voids the meeting and the vote on the merger. That’s not the only mishap we’re asking the judge to consider.
The Montana Public Service Commissioners are regulators. The PSC is one-half of a public / private partnership in Montana, over 100 years old, where a monopoly (NorthWestern) is regulated by an elected body, the PSC. The PSC’s primary responsibility is to the people who are “captured” by this monopoly. The Commissioner’s job is not to make it easy for NorthWestern Energy to speculate in the estimated $7 trillion data center market. As a regulated corporation, NorthWestern’s job is to provide the least expensive, most reliable power for its “captive” ratepayers.
For many of us in Montana, we are seeing a flashback to the 90s when Montana Power left its ratepayers behind to speculate on fiber optic communications. The company quickly went bankrupt. The PSC is supposed to learn from history and prevent such speculation.
This is a tale of two mergers, one being told to Wall Street investors, the other being told to the PSC and NorthWestern’s 400,000 Montana ratepayers. Throughout this process, NorthWestern insisted — and the PSC agreed — that this merger is not about data centers. Yet, in both the public and confidential proceedings, the utility confirmed that it told investors it would make a killing by investing in data centers in Montana. The PSC has gone along with NorthWestern’s wink and nod, which is wrong.
For the past 11 months as an intervener, 350 Montana has urged the PSC to require a comprehensive review to reveal what Montana ratepayers will face (who will pay for infrastructure, for instance, and what are the risks ratepayers face?) when these data centers arrive in our state. We brought in expert witnesses to recommend significant and explicit safeguards for ratepayers.
As a climate organization, we asked in a separate lawsuit that the PSC fully explore its responsibilities in light of the recent Held v. Montana decision, which requires that Montana agencies consider the climate costs of their decisions. Specifically, the data center development is predicted to double the amount of electricity NorthWestern provides. That doubling of electricity will most likely come from fossil fuel plants, enormously increasing greenhouse gases and rising temperatures.
NorthWestern’s executives will make $50 million in “golden parachutes” as part of this merger. If the PSC were to honor this history of public / private partnership, it should have justly compensated ratepayers. 350 Montana was adamant throughout the process that the PSC should examine and create benefits for the public equal to the benefits of the private executives. There was a one-time $10 million rate reduction in the agreement, but that works out to less than $20 a family. Instead, if developing data centers is so profitable, why not split proceeds to reduce rates for Montana’s families and businesses?
We asked the PSC to vote against this merger until the data centers were fully examined and until the merger structured benefits for the public equal — if not more significant — than the private profit of NorthWestern Energy.
Finally, the vote on November 10 was 3 to 2 in favor of the merger. But one of the elected Commissioners, Brad Molnar, was suspended for behavior unbecoming a commissioner. He was suspended after asking difficult questions to NorthWestern’s executives, more than a year after the incident in question. Governor Gianforte appointed a replacement commissioner who voted to approve the merger. If it hadn’t been for these backroom shenanigans, the merger would have failed 3 to 2.